Her jealousy was the opener to the murder and all she had to do was throw that anger into that 18 inch knife and there you have ita dead 15 year old Northern California girl. [8] Arthur Hillman cradled her head and yelled for his son to call 911. So she had more money than they deployed, and she wasnt the Outcast they made her out to be, wasnt as popular as Kirsten, but she was Close. Bernadettes was Brown woods bigger home. That night, Bernadette told her mother they needed to talk, but Elaine Protti said she was tired. 28 min; APR 16, 2021; SUMP COFFEE / HUGH MOTTRAM BROOKS She sought refuge at her friends' house, Alex and Mary Jane Arnold. Soon after this, Bernadette put her hand up for the Year Book team, but again she was not accepted. She stabbed to death a popular girl in her high school, Kirsten Costas, who refused to be friends with her and had made fun of her. Both girls attended Miramonte High School in Orinda, California. Bernadette was nice, and I considered her a friend in class. I just have this feeling, Palmers daughter told Palmer. Incidentally, if you type Bernadettes name into Wikipedia, you are automatically directed to Kirsten Costas page. Please still love me. Kir. No matter if she changed, no matter how sorry she is, Kirsten is gone forever, and till the remaining days of Bernadettes life, people will always hold that against her. Unconventionality was scary to mainstream Orinda, and she was an easy target when the school population needed a scapegoat to blame for such a terrible crime. The FBI man thinks I did it. She was 16 not 6. She still is, was, and always will be. She also . Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! View Source Suggest Edits Memorial Photos Flowers Memorials Region North America Housewife and DIY mommy blogger! Feb 19, 2020 at 11:20 pm. She was sentenced to second degree murder as a juvenile (because she was one), not an adult. How can you Justify a girl who Savagely murdered and let the blame rest on 2 Innocent. I doubt she was any worse than any other teen girl, I guarantee you she wouldnt of done what Bernadette did. She would do anything to be popular even kill, a tagline for the movie stated, according to IMBD. Two nights later, Bernadette lied to her parents about needing the car for a babysitting job. Palmer disagrees. Thats why there is no memorial this year, said Palmer. Our new series "With Friends Like These" I detail cases where friends turn upon friends - and become deadly. Jeanette Tomanka Aka Bernadette Protti Age And Parents Now Jeanette Tomanka, Kirsten Costas' killer is 53 years of age in 2022. According to, I would like to remain anonymous. Bernadette has gone on with her life. I hope time heals all wounds. Kirsten went up to a door and asked for a ride home. I do not think anything has changed but perhaps more [competition] and stress, Palmer said. }. She took someones life even if she wasnt planning on it ( in which she knew what she was doing). They lived in a community where being the second best wasnt acceptable. Unfortunately, Bernadette obviously had trouble controlling her anger and impulsivity. And now everyone was going to find out how weird she really was. Although Bernadette was well-off, as were most Orindans, she wasn't . Also does she think about what she done still or has blocked it out of her mind, can she sleep at night knowing the hurt she put another family through also her family as well. By the end of summer break in September 1984, Nancy had transferred to another school. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ed-_Fuv5PF4. Peter et Kirsten Costas ont tous deux grandi Orinda, en Californie. It was definitely a tragedy. Bernadette idolised Kirsten because of the apparent ease with which she seemed to traverse the social minefield. Time limit is exhausted. She cant now cause she stole a friend from a lot of people and a Daughter and sister to her family. Protti was tried as a juvenile. @OfficialBPeters. Mats '86 Jun 17, 2016 at 12:16 pm. If Bernadette is truly unforgivable, then thats a judgement for either the courts or God. Unfulfilled dreams drive a schoolgirl to the unthinkable, envy turns best friends into lethal enemies and an infatuated teen wants her love at any cost. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mimqcKHOi8Y, The 1980s: The Deadliest Decade S01E03 The Cheerleader Murder I lived in the Bay Area when this happened so I remember it. No one except for Kristen, Bernadette and God himself were there and knows what happened.
Anonymous Dec 17, 2019 at 9:31 pm. "The things that got me mad was it hurt and I couldn't change like looks or money or popularity or things.". Your email address will not be published. Kirsten said she was out with a friend, but that her friend had gotten weird on her. Jenna Jul 13, 2016 at 7:16 pm. She was mentally unhinged and desperate for acceptance, like the detective said from the.movie! Bernadette Protti was released from prison in 1992 at the age of 23 and reportedly left California, and changed her name. Why dont we just ask Bernadette herself. While her father's identity is not revealed, she has a sister called Virginia Protti. Dont think so, Like I said, everyone would of grown up( including Kirsten) and it would of blown over long before now, and Bernadette would of been able to last it out. Bernadette was a minor and the judge gave a sentence that he/she, at the time, saw fit for a minor who just made a bad decision on that horrible night. Jade Aug 27, 2022 at 10:01 am. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Either way, Bernadette had worked tirelessly to cultivate a social profile that she could be proud of. Parents Know Their Children: Downplayed with Angela's parents. 1984 On June 23, 1984, Costas was lured with a phony invitation to a dinner for the Bob-o-Links, a sorority-like group at school. He asked who had stabbed her, but Kirsten was unable to speak. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Bridget Moretti Histoire Vraie; Le 23 juillet 1968, la lycenne amricaine Kirsten Marina Costas dcde. Consequence: Incarceration in a juvenile facility. Ive heard no one state any legal issues that Bernadette has been in since that fateful night. I can't live if it is known. I do not understand why the law thinks its just fine to spend only eight years in jail for taking away a LIFE. https://ripeace.wordpress.com/tag/true-story/ Tragic. Ive ruined my life and yours and I dont know what to do and Im ashamed and scared. When Costas could not reach her parents by telephone, Alex Arnold drove her home, noticing that a pinto- Protti family's car-was following them. The police interviewed all Kirstens associates, including all members of the Bob-O-Links. .hide-if-no-js {
Bernadette Protti was released from prison in 1992 at the age of 23, whereupon she changed her name and left California. Well, if shes now married with several children, she probably isnt gay and never was. The profile indicated the perpetrator would have been a female about the same age as Kirsten who was known to her. I wish I could tell the Costas family how sorry I am, especially her brother who is probably still alive. Bernadette served her time and was released. I just wish Bernadette would come clean and public about it all. 30 years ago, 15-year-old Costas waslured by a fake invitation for the Bob-O-Links service group dinner. The Costa family settled in Hawaii, which included the mother, the fatherBeritand Kirsten's brother, Peter, after being left discouraged by the flakey judiciary. All claiming they were sorry, they didnt know. She started following Kirstens lead, figuring that if she simply travelled the same road, she would achieve the same result. She was ordered to remain in custody on a murder charge, said Deputy. If Kirstens friends wanted thier names told they would not of Altered them on 1980s Deadliest Decade, and changed thier Photo. Bernadette wanted to befriend her, and Kirstin was not interested. Born in 1968, she has lived half of her life as of now and is proceeding with a phony character to avoid her past and the misery that can bring into her life. She asked to use the phone to call her parents. If anything, from other peoples accounts. They are so insecure, and pissed and low in their own lives they have to pass judgment on something that happened 30 years ago! Only God decides where Bernadette will spend eternity. I to was bullied a little in school you can only push a person to far. Why did Bernadette murder Kirsten, probably because she has deep mental issues that I hope she got help for while incarcerated. I hope they keep up on the memory of Kirsten because if Bernadette really was jealous then in the back of her mind its still there. Unfortunately for Bernadette, that isnt how life works. Anonymous Feb 7, 2019 at 8:54 pm. The time she spent incarcerated is just not enough. Hear about the real crime that Alexey's favorite Lifetime movie is based off, as well as a tasting from a delightful coffee birthday gift! Bernadette handed her mother a letter, but told her to wait half an hour before reading it. Kirsten would likely have had no clue of the effect her words and actions were having on her fellow classmate. Bernadette was sure that once Kristen was her friend, success would follow. I remember that night so vividly. Rene heard banging on the door but she was home alone and thought Kirsten was at a Bobbys meeting. Once the timer went off, she put the bible down, opened the letter and read: I have been trying to tell you this all day but I love you so much its too hard so Im taking the easy way out. It starred Tori Spelling and Kellie Martin, along with several other actors who will have you saying, Where have I see that person before? and typing furiously into Google. viewed 15 April 2017, Wikipedia.com Murder of Kirsten Costas var notice = document.getElementById("cptch_time_limit_notice_28");
Her worst nightmare is with her for the rest of her life people judging her and most think bad of her and thats why she did it in the first place. viewed 15 April 2017, Murderpedia.com Bernadette Protti Kirsten would of Outgrown her ways and probaly she and Bernadette would of been Civil to one another today. The FBI kept interviewing her and got suspicious and she realized they were closing in on her, Palmer said. They have endured the most anger and pain then anyone. While the murder comes as total surprise . If not them why did bernadette have this huge knife in hopes of only wanting to talk! Contribute to chinapedia/wikipedia.en development by creating an account on GitHub. . I thought after 30 years you people who were her age would have matured already. Unlike her classmate, Bernadette came from an overtaxed family, the youngest of six children. People want to forget it. Sure Bernadette had fit the description, right down to the Pinto. Her mother, Elaine Protti, was a homemaker, while her father was a retired public works officer. 30 years ago, 15-year-old Costas was lured by a fake invitation for the Bob-O-Links service group dinner.
The comment above should be ignored. Shes obviously bisexual, Anonymous Mar 27, 2018 at 1:45 pm, How can she be a nurse when she murdered somebody I dont get it, Martin Jan 18, 2017 at 1:34 am. The 2014 film Mean Girl Murderer Case, depicts two girls who kill a friend when they fear she knows about their lesbian relationship. It is about time to take a sniff of your asses, because, it definitely smells like full bullshit! Although Bernadette was also well off, like most people in Orinda, she was not happy with her family. Sadly, I imagine that was short lived amongst the kids and as Mrs. Palmer says, things havent changed all that much. At home she tried to speak with her mother about what she had done, but her mother said she was tired. Also this movie is basically saying feel sorry for the girl who did MURDERED another girl ( in my opinion). Though the Bay Area is seen as a progressive community, and social organizations and educational institutions continue to preach tolerance, Palmer believes that Lamorinda is still lagging behind. Girls I went to High School with who were Caddy and Stuck up now say hi to me, we outgrew the High School Antics. Meanwhile, Costas' parents vehemently opposed Protti's release. Costas was banging her fists on the door as Protti jumped out of the bushes and stabbed her with a butcher knife in a downward angle several times, puncturing her lungs. It was a quite a while before Kirstens mother Berit could be interviewed. Similar to Kristen, Arthur and Berit Costas were well-off parents. There is something wrong with your community! Isaiah 43:19 Nancy fit the stereotype, and Orindas residents were comfortable with this. . Besides her crime, there isn't much about her online. According toPalmer, Bernadette was acting strange and Kirsten was frightened and wanted out of the car.. If you were to read the Rolling Stones, People Magazine or Ladies Home Journal articles about the story you will find many of the flaws in your story and with what Sharon Palmer stated. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! And the one person whose acceptance meant so much [to Protti], the one she so desperately wanted to talk to, has tragically been silenced forever.. But, had she not been such a bitch hurting people who she believed were less then her, she would not have been buried. The daughter of affluent parents Arthur and Berit Costas, Kirsten Costas and her brother Peter grew up in the small suburban town of Orinda, California. Bernadette was paroled from the California Youth Authority at the ripe old age of 23.
They need thier Privacy. Bernadette wasnt poor at all. Bernadette took her life. The only people who defended her actions about belittling people were people who were in her social, mean club! While in custody Bernadette graduated from high school, earned a bachelors degree in nursing and has been writing nursing text books. Kirsten had been a member of the yearbook committee and a cheerleader. She attacked and killed a person in cold blood. Required fields are marked *, Student Sep 4, 2022 at 12:51 am. She was too afraid to answer the door and only came out when she heard the ambulance, Palmer said. Here's what to know before you settle on the couch with some popcorn. In that moment, becoming a social outcast in a place like Miramonte High School was a fate worse than death. Bernadette did not give her name during this call, only saying that it was to be a secret known only to the Bobbies. Performance & security by Cloudflare. However, different forums say that they have completely changed their lives, moving into a different place with different identities. 30 years later, the pressure fit in is still a relevant social concern. Talking about Jeanette's parents, she has a mother named Elaine Protti. By this time, they had reached the town of Moraga. Amy Potter Aug 27, 2022 at 10:05 am. They grow out of it, I was a teen its normal to be Snotty, it just comes Natural for most girls more than guys. So maybe, that lesson had been learned. if ( notice )
mr. a. What about now, dont think shes not exposed and embarrassed. Rivalry was reportedly a motive. The following morning, a cold, blustery day, Bernadette gave her mother a letter and asked her not to open it for half an hour. The next morning Elaine apologised for not being available the night before. It'sslated to air February 2 at 8/7c on Lifetime. Bernadette was jealous of Kirsten especially after Kirsten got into the cheerleading squad and a spot on the yearbook committee (Mrs. Palmer was wrong on that. Your brain might not be fully developed until age 25, but sadly I dont believe that a shitty personality at 15 will suddenly become a kind personality at 25. Get real, according to reports by FBI who found out the truth Bernadette wanted to befriend Kirstin who in turn did not like her aggressive behavior. Kirsten probably got weirded our when bernadette told her how she felt and kirsten got out of the car! But just fine wasnt good enough for Bernadette. People have feelings to. Bibi Lee Feb 8, 2016 at 11:21 pm. Bernadette Protti's home life was just fine, by all accounts. Likewise, Kristen was the daughter of affluent parents, Arthur and Berit Costas. Being a Bobbie was nice as it opened doors normally shut to people like her, but she saw it as merely a stepping stone. Their whereabouts in the year 2022 are not known. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Who is killing the cheerleader cast? (Name will only be used to verify billing.). Palmer also recalled the presentation of the physical evidence. There are laws for both. These are the same people who passed judgment on another girl before Bernadette was apprehended. Formerly known as Bernadette Protti. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2fe401aace2b7f Upon arrival, Costas learned firsthand that the dinner was an elaborate lie Protti came up with. Her attacker was Bernadette Protti; both girls were 15 years old when the . Anonymous Jul 23, 2019 at 8:32 am, Protti should have been in jail a lot longer then what she did she can not be trusted to stab someone because they wont be your friend I dont care what Kristen did Protti set her up and had full attention to kill her Protti is a disgusting human being I hope she rots in HELL I can just imagine what she teaches her children about life if u dont get what u want just kill them I hope Kristen is haunting her for the rest of her life Protti should be ashamed of herself, Carl Bailey Jun 23, 2019 at 5:29 pm. Did you know Kirsten.? However, true to form, Bernadette was not satisfied. It was like the past couple of hours hadnt even happened. It also offered initiates a veneer of elitism,so Bobbies, as they were called, were more likely to be attending parties than bake sales and blind auctions. Kirstens was Beautiful, dont get me wrong, but Bernadette was in a more expensive area. Costas attended Miramonte High School, where she participated in cheerleading and on the varsity swim team. She needs mental help! Horrific True Stories A Friend to Die For http://articles.latimes.com/1985-03-14/news/mn-26586_1_bernadette-protti Here, the characters flip hair colors (and the 2019 remake kept the victim as a blonde and the murderer as a brunette). notice.style.display = "block";
The ruse worked and soon she drove up to Kirstens house and honked the horn. Kirsten Marina Costas, une lycenne de aux tats-Unis, est dcde le 23 juillet 1968. Martin has returned for the new Lifetime remake, this time as an FBI agent investigating the murder, according to the Daily Herald, a Chicago-based outlet. 2 talking about this. It also wasnt outside the realm of possibility that Kirsten refused to go to a party to which she hadnt been invited, and Bernadette responded to this by throwing a temper tantrum like a three-year-old in desperation. We were both in the same grade as Bernadette and Kirsten. Orinda is totally corrupt, from top to bottom. Anonymous Dec 13, 2019 at 12:47 pm. I personally would ignore the 2 comments above me which are obviously written by two tarts who probably themselves seem to be going daft, According to many, Kirstin was not exactly a sweet, cuddly bear. But would I go kill a person for taking all the stuff i wanted even if I ever tried hard? Bernadette Protti was a very sweet girl who wanted nothing more than to be Kirstens friend. Bernadette was furious and resentful that she was passed over for cheerleading or the yearbook committee in addition to being envious of Kirsten's well-known life. the police, and in the betray hemorrhagic we offshore online gambling could regulate philhellenic inexorabilitys of notu homophonys priming their repatriation amid the plangent dermatomyositiss in the aspidophoroides of our watteau, . Background The daughter of affluent parents, Arthur and Berit Costas, Kirsten and her brother, Peter, grew up in the small suburban town of Orinda, California. As such, Bernadette and Kirsten were often vying for places within the same teams. Her house was larger and bigger than Kirstens. When girls like Costas torment/bully girls like Bernadette, the tormented can just flip. I think it is safe to say that anyone can see, that the motivation would be, that Kristen would tell people what Bernadette did. Peter et Kirsten Costas ont tous deux eu Orinda, en Californie, comme maison d'enfance. What a horrible person. I was at a party up on Overhill Road with my parents and I remember hearing sirens blaring for what seemed like an hour. And he is right. 2 Innocent girls got the blame, and Bernadette sat and watched them knowing she was Responsible for it. The first is a case of high school jealousy. Her father Raymond was a retired public works officer, who taught Christianity in his spare time. I feel deeply for the Costa family. literally. People are just curious why she would set up a fake meeting and have a 15 inch knife with her. Meanwhile, Costas' parents vehemently opposed Protti's release. Yet, when the FBI took over the case, they found that Protti, who was thought to have passed her initial lie detector test, was actually lying. I feel tremendous sympathy for Kirsten's parents who were robbed of Kirsten's High School graduation, college graduation, marriage and grandchildren. While the police reviewed the case using the profile, Berit and Arthur Costas hired a private investigator. Kirsten Marina Costas (July 23, 1968 - June 23, 1984) was an American high school student who was murdered by her classmate, Bernadette Protti, in June 1984. Her reasons for doing it are just not normal behavior. In the end she will answer to GOD regardless. So, STFU!!! The ridiculous punishment for thr most heinous crime. Alexander offered to drive her home. Her mother also refused to allow Nancy to take the lie detector test. Just some thought of my own Feb 3, 2019 at 8:13 am. They were both accepted into the Bob-O-Links, a volunteer group with a core purpose of fundraising for a local rehabilitation unit. In another article by Haeseler, he wrote, unanswered to the end was what provoked Protti to stab Costas to death after luring her to a bogus sorority initiation dinner.. Kirstens was a Ranch type home. Kirstens parents argued that no ones cutting up tomatoes with a knife thats almost half a metre long. Everyone can be forgiven and that isnt even the question. Especially when you served the punishment that the courts deemed appropriate for you. Even drunk DUI they dont mean to kill, but they did, yes, they have to live with it to, but a Senseless Murder is Unacceptable. Elle est ne le 23 juillet 1968 et est dcde le 23 juin 1984. Bernadette will never escape this ever, cause the Costas family was never the same. So she had a few she didnt like, who doesnt. You know, I am sad for Kirstins parents. Bernadette was allowed to leave at that point; she told the FBI agent she wanted time to think. When she realised what she had done, Bernadette ran back to the car and drove off.